Contribution based contract

by Melinda Tung
14th August 2016

Hi all,

It's lovely to meet you all here. I have recently digitally self published my book on Amazon and have submitted my manuscript to a few publishers. 3 of them came back to me (Novum, Olympia and Austin McCauley) with the interest to publish my book on a 'contribution based contract'. They are talking about few thousand pounds. I'm not sure this is normal. After having done some research on these publishers they are placed in the category as 'vanity publishers'. I'm therefore not sure what sort of risk I'm taking if I were to go with them. Any comments and advice is very much appreciated. Many thanks. Kind regards, Melinda

Replies

Hi Melinda, I just wonder if you finally published your book at one of these publishers. In general, I think it’s quite usual to invest a bit into your own book – this will boost quality and people on the market will get to know you better. If your manuscript is convincing enough, you might have good chances to be accepted for further books in future. Has already one of you managed to get accepted by a publisher with his/her first book? Or is it more common to self publish the first book? Cheers.

Profile picture for user l.breite_66729
Lukas
Breit
330 points
Starting out
Short stories
Fiction
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Food, Drink and Cookery
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Media and Journalism
Business, Management and Education
Speculative Fiction
Adventure
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Gothic and Horror
Lukas Breit
01/07/2020

Self-publishing is really a good approach for some authors. But not for everyone. You have to remember that it's a long way from a manuscript to a good book. Of course, you can do without editing, a graphic designer and so on. But that won't get you a high-quality book. If you just want to somehow publish something you've written yourself, you can do that. Or you can get together the various service providers that are needed to make the book really good. I think that service providers like Novum Publishing can be a professional option if you don't have time for the time-consuming process of self-publishing yourself. You also have to remember with self-publishing that you also have to pay for all the services you use.

I think it's most important to have realistic expectations before publishing a book and to compare the different ways you can publish a book. Not all options fit equally well for every author. And before signing a contract, it makes sense to read it thoroughly and consider whether the terms suit you. As a new author, you will practically never be able to get a contract with a traditional publisher, so in my opinion it makes sense to consider whether there are any alternatives, and if so, which ones.

Profile picture for user Catherine Bauer
Catherine
Bauer
120 points
Practical publishing
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Historical
Romance
Young Adult (YA)
Competitions, opportunities and groups
The writing process
The publishing process
Self-Publishing
Artists
Creative Writing and Publishing
Media and Journalism
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Film, Music, Theatre, TV and Radio
Writing and Editing
How publishers work
Crowdfunding
Catherine Bauer

In reply to by l.breite_66729

18/02/2021

I too have just today received the same contribution-based offer of a contract. "Contribution" aside, there is no way I will agree to editing changes and deletions of my book - I agree. As I read it through, a really bad negative feeling enveloped me... and I have learned to follow my instincts where contracts are concerned.

Profile picture for user ariel.br_57089
Ariel
Brown
270 points
Developing your craft
Ariel Brown
10/08/2018

I have just had exactly the same thing from olympia and have had to look into them. I have been told that publishers would not ask up-front payment and would take a cut of the profit of your book when sold.

I have quickly gone off the idea of using them, even though they liked my manuscript. It sounds like they like everyones

Profile picture for user wannieb
Wayne
Bristow
270 points
Ready to publish
Fiction
Wayne Bristow
05/09/2016