Description or dialogue?

by Cory Varney
28th July 2014

I'm writing my way through my first novel, second draft now. The first one was unsuccessful. Prior to writing this, I mostly wrote screenplays amongst other things - so I've got into the habit of lots of dialogue. I think the problem I'm encountering is my book is too dialogue-y, there's not enough description in there, if that makes sense?

I just wondered what people think, do you need flowing passages of description or can shorter/snappier description intertwined with plenty of dialogue work best? Just trying to strike that winning formula!

Replies

I too used to write TV scripts where you add your own camera instructions if you think it necessary, or a particular look on an actors face, so I originally found it a struggle to write a novel. Now I just get on with it and pass it over to my partner who proof reads it for me because my grammar is rubbish anyway!

Profile picture for user peter@ca_29674
Peter
Cain
85 points
Practical publishing
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Comic
Business, Management and Education
Speculative Fiction
Sports
Peter Cain
01/08/2014

I believe you have to lead your reader through the story so dialogue is necessary to portray what is happening in real time - the time of the action/reaction, but you do need some narrative. That is what storytelling is about. Make your readers feel the emotions and motivations of your characters. They also need to know 'where' and 'when' they are. That is where descriptive storytelling can be challenging. i.e. don't bore with detail, but invite the reader to picture the situation, place and time. I like to make the characters use their senses because the reader is open to autosuggestion by feeling what the character is sensing.

Profile picture for user veefallo_31252
VW
Selburn
270 points
Practical publishing
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Business, Management and Education
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
VW Selburn
28/07/2014

Thanks for the feedback guys. There's some really good tips there :) I'll definitely have a go at writing the dialogue first and seeing what I can come up with :)

Profile picture for user clv32@ho_20366
Cory
Varney
270 points
Developing your craft
Cory Varney
28/07/2014