Description or dialogue?

by Cory Varney
28th July 2014

I'm writing my way through my first novel, second draft now. The first one was unsuccessful. Prior to writing this, I mostly wrote screenplays amongst other things - so I've got into the habit of lots of dialogue. I think the problem I'm encountering is my book is too dialogue-y, there's not enough description in there, if that makes sense?

I just wondered what people think, do you need flowing passages of description or can shorter/snappier description intertwined with plenty of dialogue work best? Just trying to strike that winning formula!

Replies

I have never thought of doing that Lauriksha. You must have some plan of the scene you are writing before you start though, don't you? I am dreadful about planning - I think up the overall idea and synopsis for a novel, characterise it, and then I start writing without having planned it out scene by scene. I have just uploaded to my Kindle a book called 'Start Writing Your Novel in the Middle' or something like that. The whole idea amazed me so I had to have the book!

Profile picture for user sue@land_7773
Sue
Oxley
270 points
Ready to publish
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Media and Journalism
Speculative Fiction
Historical
Philosophy and Religion
Sue Oxley
28/07/2014

I have to say, I agree with Sue. I also have a problem with sometimes putting in too much dialogue :) It's a pain, since you want your story to flow and give off the vibe you're imagining in your head and it's difficult to that writing descriptions in between conversations and interactions.

What I've found helps me, is if I write all the dialogue first, and thereafter return to the beginning of the scene and imagine all the things I would notice or see or hear or smell or whatever, and input little descriptions; not too long that it takes away from the flow of the dialogue, but enough so that the reader feels like they're standing right there, or are involved in the scene itself. Hope that helps :)

Profile picture for user laura.to_23843
Lauriksha Venushka
Dhewlall
270 points
Developing your craft
Lauriksha Venushka Dhewlall
28/07/2014

I love short and snappy dialogue Cory, with description that isn't over long but sums up a place perfectly. I can sometimes believe that I have been to Louisianna in the States, because of James Lee Burke's amazing descriptions in his Robicheaux books, especially the smells, and I love the clarity of his writing overall.

I also love Stephen King for dialogue and for grabbing your attention and never letting you go. Whenever I get stuck I go and read some good modern literature, with a small l!, and then get excited enough to write something myself.

Profile picture for user sue@land_7773
Sue
Oxley
270 points
Ready to publish
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Media and Journalism
Speculative Fiction
Historical
Philosophy and Religion
Sue Oxley
28/07/2014